Judging Criteria

 

There are five stages of competition, consisiting of: Private Interview, Talent, Swimsuit, Eveningwear, and On Stage Question. Below you will find the judging criteria for each category.

 

1. PRIVATE INTERVIEW (25% of score): Each contestant participates in an individual 10-minute press conference-style interview with our panel of judges (12 minutes at the state and national competitions). There are typically 5 to 7 judges on a panel. Contestants are questioned on their background as presented on their fact sheet, their educational and career goals, their opinions on current events and social issues, and their interests, hobbies and extracurricular activities.

Scoring is based on:

  • Qualities and attributes of a Miss America

  • Overall first impression

  • Validated aspirations, opinions and responses in context

  • Poise, personal appearance and attractiveness

  • Personality, intelligence, style and emotional control

  • Speech, vocabulary and grammar

  • Confident and commanding presence

  • Knowledge, understanding and ability to articulate her platform issue

  • Sense of accomplishment

  • Ability to fulfill job responsibilities of Miss San Fernando Valley/Miss Woodland Hills

 

2. TALENT (35% of score): Contestants perform a 90-second routine of their own choosing. Some possible talents include all types of singing, dancing, gymnastics, instrumental music, dramatic or comedy monologues, baton twirling and ventriloquism. Other talents that can be performed solo on a stage are also possible. Contact us if you have a question about your talent presentation. 
Scoring is based on:

  • Talent selection and performance, as it distinguishes both the contestant's skills and personality

  • Interpretive ability

  • Technical skill level (execution, technique, synchronization, control)

  • Stage presence and on-stage personality

  • Totality of all elements (including costume, props, voice, use of body, choreography)

 

3. LIFESTYLE & FITNESS IN SWIMSUIT (15% of score): Each contestant briefly appears on stage in a one- or two-piece swimsuit and footwear of her own choosing. Swimsuits must be approved prior to competition by the Executive Director of the pageant. 
Scoring is based on:

  • Qualities and attributes of a Miss America

  • Overall first impression

  • Statement of strong physical fitness and health

  • Sense of attractiveness and presence

  • Display of energy, charisma and expression

  • Sense of confidence and composure

 

4. ON STAGE QUESTION (5% of score): Questions will be of a general nature and will be neither platform-related nor something taken directly from the private interview. The objective is to evaluate the contestant's ability to think on her feet and answer a question of general interest to people her age, including, but not limited to, local, state and national current events. 
Scoring is based on:

  • Overall first impression

  • Extemporaneous response to on-stage question

  • Did the contestant answer the question in the context in which it was asked?

  • Can she handle the pressure of speaking on stage in front of an audience?

  • Will young people see her as a role model who is reflective of today's generation?

 

5. EVENING WEAR (20% of score): Each contestant appears on stage in an outfit of her own choosing, representative of what she would wear to a formal "after five" social event. Pant suits, cocktail dresses and evening gowns are all appropriate for this phase of the competition; however, evening gowns are most common. 
Scoring is based on:

  • Qualities and attributes of a Miss America

  • Overall first impression

  • Sense of confidence, personality and stage presence

  • Walk, posture, carriage and grace

  • Appropriateness of attire and sense of style

  • Sense of attractiveness, beauty and charm

 

TOP 5 BALLOT: From the above 100%, the Top Five Finalists will be identified to the judges. The Top Five Finalists enter this final round of balloting with zero points. Each judge will then rank the contestants in the order they individually believe the contestants should finish on a Final Ballot. A first place vote is worth ten points, a second place vote is worth five points, a third place vote is worth three points, a fourth place vote is worth two points and a fifth place vote is worth one point . The total of the Final Ballots alone will determine the outcome of the pageant. The high and low scores on the Final Ballot will NOT be dropped. All judges’ votes count on the Final Ballot.

©2014 by Miss San Fernando Valley. 

All crown images are courtesy of Damion Lloyd Photography.

Titleholder photos are courtesy of Rachel Berry Photography.

  • Wix Facebook page
  • Instagram App Icon
  • Wix Twitter page